Wow Christopher, way to steal their song and the Native American's land
Wooo, ok, so do you know that one song? You probably don't, it was just released. It's called Dark Corner Dance Floor by the band Phantastic Ferniture (I know, its an interesting name). I love this song, and the lyrics are the best part! So, here is how it goes, the main singer sings ♫"I just want to find a home (all on my own)"♫, like she is invading some place, calling it hers, and then taking all the credit. Ha, Its great. Then she sings ♫"Don't you come on my side of town"♫, referring to Native Americans or something like that, and telling them to get off her land and out of her home. Wait a sec....that sounds like Christopher Columbus, doesn't it? Hmm, i'll stop rambling on about music and explain his story.
In 1492, Christopher Columbus sailed across the Atlantic Ocean and stumbled upon land that wasn't Europe. When he reached this land, now known as America, he believed he was the first to discover it. Even though "Indigenous people had been living there for centuries by the time Columbus arrived in 1492" (Yan). Didn't he realize that he wasn't the first to arrive when he saw Native Americans who were already living there? Hmm, maybe he just pretended and took all the credit for himself! Anyways, he made it to America, so we should give him some credit. I mean hey, its a honor to have a whole day dedicated to yourself, so he does have some credit for what he (thought he) discovered. But, because Columbus earned a day for "discovering America", the people who really discovered it should have their own day. How about Indigenous People's Day? That sounds realistic and historically accurate. Let me explain why, first of all, Columbus is not a nice person. When he first meant the Native Americans, he wrote that they were friendly and well-built people. Although, he caused all kinds of trouble for them. He treated them very brutally and forced them into slavery. Furthermore, he passed along a terrible disease that killed many native Americans. Christopher Columbus saw the Native Americans as hard-working slaves who would make him rich, but the Native Americans saw Columbus as a murderer and an invader.
Sources:
- https://www.biography.com/news/christopher-columbus-day-facts
- https://www.cnn.com/2018/10/08/us/columbus-day-vs-indigenous-peoples-day/index.html

Very thoughtful analysis about Columbus day Olivia! I thought it was very neat for you to add song lyrics and say how Columbus basically followed their song.. Do you still think that after all the bad things that he did, should he still have a day named after him? Or do you think that it is necessary for it be replaced by Indigenous People's day?
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your connection of Columbus to the song and found it very thoughtful and interesting. I also thought your idea of Columbus potentially pretending to discover America to take the credit himself was interesting because I've never heard a theory like that before. Do you believe there is any way Columbus Day and Indigenous People's Day could coexist? And if they did, would it cause more riots and disputes among Americans?
ReplyDeleteI found your informal language in this reflection very intriguing; I’m not used to hearing such informal language being in AP English, but I find that it really works for you! Using such familiar language made the piece more relatable and a more interesting read. Also, I love your comparison of history to a song, as well as the music embedded in certain words. It’s refreshing, creative, and very “you”. Way to go Olivia!
ReplyDelete